On Mon, 2004-01-26 at 08:55, Vladimir B. Savkin wrote:
> On Mon, Jan 26, 2004 at 08:38:33AM -0500, jamal wrote:
> > I cant say i doubt you, but your word alone is insufficient data ;->
>
> You can see for youself. Police users' traffic to half of the normal rate
> and here them scream :) Then change policing to shaping using wrr
> (or htb class for each user), and sfq on the leafs, and users are happy.
>
;-> Sorry I dont have time. But this could be a nice paper since
i havent seen this topic covered. If you want to write one i could
help provide you an outline.
> Well, I use wrr + sfq exactly for fairness. No such thing can be
> achieved with policing only.
>
Thats what i was assuming. Shaping alone is insufficient as well.
> Here it is:
>
> +---------+ +-ppp0- ... - client0
> | +-eth1-<+-ppp1- ... - client1
> Internet ----- eth0-+ router | . . . . . . . .
> | +-eth2-< . . . . . .
> +---------+ +-pppN- ... - clientN
>
>
> Traffic flows from internet to clients.
> The ethX names are for example only, my setup is more complex actually,
> but that complexity is not related to IMQ or traffic shaping.
> Clients use PPTP or PPPoE to connect to router.
> See, there's no single interface I can attach qdisc to, if I want
> to put all clients into the same qdisc.
>
So why cant you attach a ingress qdisc on eth1-2 and use policing to
mark excess traffic (not drop)? On eth0 all you do is based on the mark
you stash them on a different class i.e move the stuff you have on
IMQ0 to eth0.
Example on ingress:
meter1=" police index 1 rate $CIR1"
meter1a=" police index 2 rate $PIR1"
index 2 is shared by all flows for default.
index 1 (and others) is guaranteeing rate (20Kbps) for each of the flows
etc.
Look for example at examples/Edge32-ca-u32
The most important thing to know is that policers can be shared across
devices, flows etc using the "index" operator.
I just noticed you are copying linux-kernel. Please take it off the list
in your response, this is a netdev issue. This should warn anyone
interested in the thread to join netdev.
cheers,
jamal
|